Lighting: Color Temperature theory and checking out lighting instruments.
When checking out lighting instruments please be aware of color temperature issues.
Color temperature theory – a short course.
If you were to take a piece of cold steel rod with no heat applied there would be no light energy emanating from it. If you were to place one end of that piece of steel into a furnace, the metal would first turn a brown red color. As more heat is applied the red tip of the steel would turn a bright red, even orange. Even more heat would then shift the color to a whiter looking yellow color. Finally as the tip heats up even further the tip of steel would appear to look entirely white.
The following list comes from Artist-Blacksmith’s Association of North America Inc. and lists the color of steel as it heats up. All the numbers following the color are Fahrenheit:
brown red: 1110F
blood red: 1200F
dark cherry:1290F
cherry: 1400F
light cherry:1490F
light red: 1600F
orange: 1710F
light orange:1800F
Yellow: 1920F
light yellow:2010F
white: 2190-about 2490F
incandescent:above 2490FAbove list obtained from http://www.abana.org/discus/messages/5/48.html
See also: http://www.abana.org/resources/education/tempil_guide.html
In a nut shell, what took place as the steel tip was being heated up was the atoms of steel electrons were first outputting long wavelengths of light. As more heat is applied the long wavelengths shorten to represent a higher energy level attained by the heated tip. As the wavelengths shorten the color temperature Kelvin number goes up.
Please understand that the voltage supplied to a lighting instrument is similar to a furnace. As the voltage goes up, the filament will send out shorter wave length light. The color shift, on tungsten instruments, will shift toward blue. Too high a voltage will obviously blow the bulb so this is for discussion only. If you decrease the voltage to a lighting instrument bulb the shift will go toward red. This can be done thought the use of dimmers. Please note that you can dim some lighting instruments like tungsten halogen but other lighting instruments can not be dimmed. When dimming tungsten halogen you can safely do so about 10% before the halogen cycle will fail to clear the bulb of tungsten residue build up. As you decrease the voltage to the tungsten bulb the light from that bulb will shift to red because of the diminished energy used to heat the instrument.
There are two principal color temperature lighting fixtures, 3200 and 5000 Kelvin.
From the theory section above, you should understand that 3200 represents lighting that comes close to lights one would find in the home, from incandescent fixtures. Conversely, the higher Kelvin number of 5000 represents the light coming from the sun.
Some typical color temperatures are:
1500 k Candlelight
2680 k 40 W incandescent lamp
3000 k 200 W incandescent lamp
3200 k Sunrise/sunset, and 3200K location and studio lighting.
3400 k Tungsten lamp
3400 k 1 hour from dusk/dawn
5000-4500 k Xenon lamp/light arc
5400 HMI
5500 k Sunny daylight around noon
5500-5600 k Electronic photo flash
6500-7500 k Overcast sky
9000-12000 k Blue skyAbove list obtained from: http://www.schorsch.com/kbase/glossary/cct.html but modified with additions by Donald McLaren.
Convention: do not mix lighting sources when shooting video or film. When shooting film match the lighting to the type of film. This is a basic mistake made by beginning students. It is quite easy for an instructor to spot this type of mistake as parts of the picture might be seen as blue while other parts of the scene will be red in color cast. The reason one would see two color casts is that the ambient light is typically one color but the lights that the student brings to the shoot do not match in color temperature.
Exception: The TV show NYPD Blue uses a blend of color temperatures. They color balance the cameras to be between daylight and tungsten. When they shoot, you will see the slight blue cast of daylight and the slight cast of red of practicles. The shift is slight because the camera is in-between the two extremes. Also, they allow light to come into the scene that they can not control and blow out the exposure. These are professionals and know when and how to break with convention.
Example: If you are shooting with daylight film then check out lights that are around 5000 Kelvin.
Daylight Film (expects “blue” white light)
HMI lights are blue, typically matched for daylight, so use them straight – no filter. Florescent lights (Kino Flow) with 5000 Kelvin tubes. Tungsten Halogen 3200K with blue filter, CTB. Most of these instruments are 3200K and need a blue filter. Tungsten Halogen with 5600K bulb – no filter. (We do not have this type of bulb, so use a filter instead. Just understand that this is a rental house option.) When shooting indoors and daylight is coming through the window no filter is necessary except maybe a ND. When shooting indoors and existing practicals are being used, gel or relamp the instruments with 5000k unless you want the red, ruddy look of the practicals.
Example: If you are shooting with indoor film then check out lights that are 3200 Kelvin.
Indoor Film (expects “red” white light)
Tungsten Halogen 3200K – no filters needed. Florescent lights (Kino Flow) with 3200 Kelvin tubes. HMI puts out daylight so an orange filter is required, CTO. When shooting indoors and outside sun light comes through a window, gel outside windows with orange filter with or without ND. Installing gels on windows can run into money. When shooting indoors and existing practicals are being used, that’s just fine. The practicle color temperature is close enough.
Vocabulary term: PRACTICLES
1. A light that will or might appear in a shot such as a table lamp, floor lamp, street lamp, etc.
2. A lamp that would normally be seen in a shot for that type of location.
3. A light that can be placed into a shot, with the intention of being seen, thus allowing the lighting people to place another light, not seen, typically above, that supplies a more precisely controlled amount and directed light.
4. A light that allows motivated light, other lights to be used out of sight.
5. Director of Photography, Lighting Designers, Lighting Directors typically plead with the set designers to include practicles throughout the set so they can achieve motivated light sources from these practicles.
Question: Why can’t I see the color change of different light sources with my eyes but my video camera shows those differences up as drastic color changes.
Answer: Our eye, brain, system has an automatic color temperature system that will minimize the effect while video and film cameras are locked in their rendition of what is viewed. The video camera typically does have a white balance function that allows the camera to shift to the correct temperature.Following are some examples of gel filters used to correct “wrong” color lighting instruments.
Full CTB gel is used on our 3200 tungsten instruments.
Light loss: 1.7 stops typical
Transmission: 24% typical.
Converts To 3200K 5500K 5600K 34,480K 2210K 3200K 3130 5600K
Vocabulary Term: CTB, Color temperature blue.This is a blue gel that converts 3200K lighting instuments to function in circumstances where daylight color temperature is required.
FULL CTO gel can be used on HMI lights to allow those instruments to be used with 3200K.
Light loss: .5 stops typical
Transmission: 62%
Converts To 3200K 2180K 5600K 3090K 6010K 3200K 30,689K 5600K
Vocabulary Term: CTO, Color Temp OrangeColor temperature orange refers to a filter that is used to shift the white blue cast light comming from 5000K instuments and shifts that light down to a warmer temperature of 3200K.
Ideally: It should be noted that to use a lighting instrument that is directly inappropriate and requires a gel to bring the light into the correct temperature is wasteful. Any gel has a ND factor, a neutral density, that cuts down on the amount of light that reaches the scene.
Reality: Do what it takes to get the lighting job done. If that requires putting up a gel then do it. Just remember that you might have to put up two lights of the wrong type against one light of the correct color temperature type to get the job done due to the ND factor.
Vocabulary Term: ND or Neutral DensityND or Neutral Density is the amount of light that is decreased by going through a filter. Typically this refers to a neutral color such as a shade of gray that will not shift the original light to a new different color. Now saying that, every color filter besides shifting the output color to some new shade must also have a ND factor included. Just think in your mind of a slightly rosy filter. By being slightly red in color it will pass most of the light. Now think of a dark red filter. By making the resulting light dark red it also cuts down the light a lot. It is said to have a higher ND factor. When selecting filters, just beware that when you slide a color filter into a lighting instrument, the amount of light falling on the set from that light will decrease.Realize that there are ND filters that you can use to cut down the amount of light reaching the set but do not change the color. You can recognize these filters by their color – shade of grey to black.
Here is an example of one manufacturer, GamColor, neutral density filters.
Gam Color Filter number
ND Factor
Light loss in F stops
1514
.15 ND
.5 Stops
1515
.3 ND
.9 Stops
1516
.6 ND
1.7 Stops
1517
.9 ND
2.5 Stops
1518
1.2 ND
2.7 Stops
Dichroic Filters
Dichroic filters may be the best solution for filtering “wrong” lighting instruments for the following reasons:
- Dichroic filters reflect unwanted wavelengths back to the light source. Gel filters absorb the unwanted wavelengths and dissipate them in the form of heat, ultimately leading to performance degradation (melting, bleaching out, scorching, etc.).
- Dichroic filter transmission levels are substantially higher than an equivalent gel filter providing considerable savings in energy and money.
- Dichroic filters are highly color selective producing brighter, cleaner appearing, saturated color.
- Dichroic filters will not melt, wrinkle, shrink or fade like gel filters.
- Dichroic filters retain their characteristic spectral transmission properties indefinitely for long life and value.
- Dichroic filters are low maintenance and seldom if ever require replacement.
- Dichroic filters offer superior performance and long term cost savings.
The above list was obtained from http://www.highend.com/news/dichroic.html.
The down side of dichroic filters are listed next:
- They break easily.
- They are expensive compared to gels.
- Gel filters can be attached to just about any lighting instrument. Dicroic filters usually have to be made for a particular instrument.
- Some college campus equipment check out rooms not have any of these filters because, in the hands of students, they would not last very long.
